(The images below are thumbnails – click on them to see larger versions.)

Three more magnificent musical films belong on the list of all-time greats. Although filmed by three different studios, all were created by alumni of Arthur Freed's legendary production unit at MGM.

Funny Face
Funny Face (1957) was conceived at MGM, but when Paramount refused to loan out Audrey Hepburn, members of the Freed unit (which was being disbanded) went to Paramount. Arthur Freed's longtime associate Roger Edens produced, Stanley Donen directed, and singer-composer Kay Thompson (Edens' longtime MGM colleague) gave a film-stealing performance as a ruthless fashion magnate. Fred Astaire made everything from a raincoat to an umbrella come alive as dance partners in "Let's Kiss and Make Up." The score consisted of four classic George and Ira Gershwin songs, with several new numbers by Edens and Leonard Gershe. Hepburn gave a disarming performance as an intellectual beauty wooed by photographer Astaire when they work on one of Thompson's Paris fashion shows.

Impressive as the cast and score are, it is Donen's unique sense of cinematic flow that makes film a masterpiece. Every song flows out of the action surrounding it, and unforgettable images abound. Cineast's have long treasured Hepburn's exuberant descent down a staircase in the Louvre, waving a red tulle wrap in imitation of the massive sculpture "Winged Victory." Although visually stunning and thoroughly entertaining, Funny Face was such a box office disappointment that Paramount stopped making musicals altogether, and MGM allowed the Freed unit to melt away . However, the film developed a dedicated following over time and remains a great favorite with film buffs.

A Star is Born
Warner Brothers' most masterful 1950s musical was built by another stellar team of MGM alumni: director George Cukor, screenwriter Moss Hart, composer Harold Arlen, lyricist Ira Gershwin and performer Judy Garland. The magnificent A Star is Born (1954) was based on a classic 1937 tearjerker about an unknown actress surviving Hollywood stardom and personal heartbreak. After months of long and tortured filming, Garland gave the most spontaneous and powerful screen performance of her career, while Cukor and company made "The Man That Got Away" and other songs emotional highpoints that fit seamlessly into the story. 

Convinced that A Star Is Born was too long, Warners executives cut 27 minutes from all prints soon after the premiere. As a result, most audiences saw a confusing, incomplete version. It was not until an archival restoration in 1983 that the true impact of the film could be appreciated. The "Born in a Trunk" sequence (scored without credit by MGM's Roger Edens) had always been praised, but "Lose That Long Face" and other restored scenes make this the best screen performance of Garland's career. That Hollywood's greatest musical star did not receive an Academy Award for her finest performance remains one of the saddest injustices ever perpetrated in an unjust business. (You have to see winner Grace Kelly's pallid work in The Country Girl to know how senseless this choice was.)

Gigi: MGM's Finale
MGM had dismissed it's contract employees, but a defiant Arthur Freed pulled together one last triumph. At the urging of director Vincente Minnelli, Freed called in My Fair Lady's Alan Jay Lerner and Frederick Loewe to musicalize French novelist Colette's story of a young girl who is raised to be a courtesan but manages instead to fall in love with (and marry!) a millionaire. The result was Gigi (1959). The cast included Leslie Caron as the title character, Hermoine Gingold as her protective grandmother and Louis Jourdan as the millionaire. Maurice Chevalier, his roguish charm as irresistible as ever, made a triumphant return to the musical screen as Jourdan's aging playboy uncle.

Gigi had minimal choreography, but the score ("Thank Heaven For Little Girls," "The Night They Invented Champagne," "Gigi") and ingenious screenplay made the unsavory subject matter into a surprising, sophisticated hit. Where other film makers settled for a standard postcard vision of Paris, Minnelli shows the city from the everyday perspective of Parisians. Instead of gazing at the Eiffel Tower from a distance, we travel beneath it; instead of glittering hotel or romanticized garret, we see a frowsy bourgeois apartment. Minnelli also makes amazing use of light and shadow. In one sequence, a pensive Jourdan is silhouetted against illuminated fountains, communicating a key moment of revelation with a few mute movements – the sort of pure cinematic magic that could never be accomplished on stage.

Despite Gigi's tremendous critical and commercial success, MGM's Freed unit passed into history. Producer Arthur Freed and his associates would not receive their full due until the release of That's Entertainment (1974) reminded the world what a rich legacy they had left behind. 

Gigi was Freed's last original musical, and the line begun in The Wizard of Oz and continued through Meet Me in St. Louis, On the Town and Siingin' in the Rain came to an end in one of the ritziest films ever. Here is a musical that uses decor, color, motion, even the juxtaposition of true locale and sound stage, for tone . . . Minnelli makes a movie, as Lubitsch and Mamoulian did when almost no one else knew what a musical was, and as few knew now that musicals were turning into Broadway souvenirs.
- Ethan Mordden, The Hollywood Musical (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1981), p. 198.

Why Are These Musicals "The Best"?
The seven 1950s film musicals we've just discussed have two common factors. First, all seven set their musical numbers in the context of everyday life. Gigi has Maurice Chevalier sits in the middle of a bustling city park and sings right to the camera about girls whose beauty can send men "crashing through the ceiling." In Seven Brides for Seven Brothers, a septet of mountain men in the Wild West win feminine attention by kicking up a macho storm at a town dance. 

While stage musicals had long since relied on this blend of song with real life activities, it had only been tried on film by a few experimenters like Rodgers and Hart (i.e. - in Love Me Tonight's pass-the-song-along "Isn't It Romantic" sequence). Minnelli toyed with the concept in Meet Me In St. Louis, but compromised by presenting most of the songs proscenium-style (framed in windows or doorways) or on a raised space with an audience (the top of a trolley).

Another key issue in these films – the songs were sensational. When Judy Garland sets A Star is Born smoldering with her rendition of "The Man That Got Away," Harold Arlen's music and Ira Gershwin's lyric matter just as much (if not more than) the visually arresting presentation. Whether pain-filled, witty or celebratory, 1950s screen musicals used some of the finest songs in the history of American popular music. (Of course, this is a qualified distinction. An American in Paris, Funny Face and Singin' in the Rain resurrected many existing hit tunes, so the songs were actually written over a period of several decades.)

The next decade would bring the most profitable musical films of all time. Almost all would be adaptations of Broadway shows, but there was an occasional "spoonful of sugar" to help the medicine go down.